Choosing Projects to Show in a Portfolio
Every creative or technical professional hits the same wall: you have years of work, and a portfolio has room for only a handful of pieces. Deciding which portfolio projects to include is less about taste and more about strategy. The wrong selection makes you look scattered; the right one makes a stranger think, “That’s exactly who I need.”
This article gives you a repeatable method for choosing, ordering and, importantly, cutting projects.
Start from the audience, not the archive
Most people begin by scrolling through everything they have made and picking what they like. That produces a portfolio about you. A better starting point is the question: who should look at this, and what do I want them to do afterwards?
A recruiter reviewing dozens of applications wants evidence that you can handle the role. A small-business owner wants proof you have solved a similar problem. A fellow professional might want to see craft. Write down your target audience and the kind of work you want more of. That list becomes your filter.
A blunt but useful rule: your portfolio should show the work you want to be hired for, not the work you have been hired for. If you have spent years on routine tasks but want to move towards more strategic projects, give those the space.
Build a longlist, then score it
Gather every candidate piece into one list. Aim for twenty or so; if you have fewer, that is fine. Then score each one from 1 to 5 against criteria like these:
| Criterion | Question to ask |
|---|---|
| Relevance | Does it match the work I want next? |
| Quality | Would I be proud if this were the only thing someone saw? |
| Clarity | Can I explain the problem, my role and the outcome simply? |
| Evidence | Do I have real material to show: process, results, feedback? |
| Variety | Does it add something the other pieces don’t? |
Add the scores and sort. Do not be sentimental about what rises or falls. A project that took you six months but doesn’t score well on relevance or quality may not belong, however much effort it consumed.
How many projects is enough?
There is no magic number, but a range of four to eight works for most people. Fewer than four can look thin, and more than eight tends to dilute your best material. If you have a lot of strong work, group it into categories or add a separate archive page, while keeping the main view tight.
Quantity also depends on depth. If each project has a detailed case study, three or four may be plenty. If each is a single image with a caption, you can show more.
Balance the set
Once you’ve shortlisted, check the mix:
- Range within a focus. Show you can handle different kinds of problems within your specialism, not every discipline you’ve touched.
- Scale. A small quick project and a bigger, more complex one demonstrate flexibility.
- Process and result. Include at least a couple of pieces where you can explain your thinking, not just show the finished output.
- Recency. Prefer recent work. Older pieces can stay if they remain among your best, but be wary of anything that signals outdated skills or tools.
If you work across two distinct areas, such as illustration and web development, consider whether they belong on the same site. Sometimes two clear portfolios, or a clearly separated section, serve each audience better than a blended one.
Order matters
Visitors form an impression within seconds and often leave after the first few items. A common ordering approach:
- Lead with your strongest, most relevant piece. It sets expectations.
- End with your second strongest. People remember the final item.
- Place the remaining pieces in the middle, varying them so that neighbouring items don’t look the same.
On a homepage grid, the top-left position gets the most attention. Put your best foot forward there.
What if you don’t have client work?
Many people who are starting out, changing careers, or working under non-disclosure agreements face this. You have several honest options:
- Self-initiated projects. Design the app you wish existed, write the article you wish had been written. State clearly that it is a personal project.
- Volunteer or community work. Local charities and small groups often welcome help and can provide real constraints.
- Redesigns or critiques. If you rework an existing product or page, label it as a concept and avoid implying any relationship with the owner. Do not use someone else’s brand in a way that suggests you were commissioned.
- Collaborations and open-source contributions. Describe your specific contribution.
- Course or training projects. Fine, if described as such and treated with the same standard of care.
What you should never do is pass off someone else’s work as yours or imply a client relationship that didn’t exist. Credit collaborators and be specific about your role.
Handling confidential or restricted work
If you’ve signed a non-disclosure agreement, check what you may share. Options include:
- Asking the client for permission to show specific pieces
- Anonymising the client (“a mid-sized logistics company”) and removing sensitive details
- Describing the problem and your approach without showing confidential visuals or data
- Creating a sanitised version that recreates the process using fictional content
Never publish confidential material without permission. It can cost you the relationship and your reputation.
Decide what to cut
Cutting is the hard part. Use these tests:
- The embarrassment test. If you wince whenever someone opens it, remove it.
- The “so what” test. If you can’t say why it matters in one sentence, it probably doesn’t.
- The duplication test. If two projects show the same skill in the same way, keep the better one.
- The mismatch test. If it attracts the kind of work you no longer want, it doesn’t belong on the main page.
You do not have to delete work permanently. Keep a private archive so you can pull a piece back in when a particular client asks about something specific.
Present each choice well
Selecting the project is half the job; how you present it counts too. For each piece:
- Write a short, clear title and a one-sentence summary.
- State your role and the context.
- Show a few high-quality images or screens, not twenty.
- Add a brief note on the outcome, if you can share one truthfully.
Our guide to how to photograph or present your work well covers the visual side, and our article on case study writing for creative portfolios helps with the narrative.
A quick selection example
Imagine a freelance web designer with fifteen past projects who wants more work with independent shops. She scores her list and notices that three e-commerce redesigns rank highest for relevance, a bakery site and a bookshop site show strong visuals, and a corporate intranet project, though large, matches none of the work she wants. She chooses six: the three e-commerce redesigns, the bakery site, the bookshop site, and a small personal project that explores a checkout idea. She moves the intranet project to her archive. Her portfolio is now smaller but unmistakably aimed at one audience.
Review on a schedule
Revisit your selection every few months, or whenever you complete something strong. Swap in new work, remove the weakest piece, and re-check that the overall story still matches your goals. A portfolio is a living document, and a light, regular edit is easier than a heroic overhaul once a year.
Case Study Writing for Creative Portfolios
How to Photograph or Present Your Work Well
Frequently asked questions
How many portfolio projects should I include?
Four to eight is a good range for most people. Choose depth and relevance over volume.
Should I include old work?
Only if it still ranks among your best and doesn’t make your skills look dated. Otherwise move it to an archive.
Can I show personal projects instead of client work?
Yes, if you label them accurately. A well-executed personal project can show initiative and skill.
What if my best work is under NDA?
Ask for permission, anonymise details, or describe your process without confidential material.
Conclusion
Choosing portfolio projects comes down to knowing your audience, scoring your work honestly, balancing the set, and cutting what doesn’t serve your goals. Keep the group small, lead with strength, and be truthful about your role. A focused selection is the clearest way of telling people what you do and who you do it for.